Now we are down to the final 8, so who went home tonight and could the judges have saved them? Megan Joy was the one that received the least amount of votes from her performance last night on American Idol. When asked about what she thought on what Simon said about her performance, she said she loved Simon but she doesn’t care. At the end the judges were asked if they would consider saving her after her last performance and Simon responded by saying that just like she didn’t care about their criticism of her performance, they feel the same about not saving her and so they weren’t even going to consider it. OUCH! Maybe, just maybe she could have been the one they would have saved if she had never made that comment, but who knows, quite frankly her time was up. Next week, they will all be singing songs from the year they were born.